Everything we've purchased from Citarella's has been outstanding. Their marinades are seriously outrageous. If you're having people over to BBQ (or it's just your own family) grab your meats HERE. You will not regret it. Amazing.
If you are looking for ambiance or fluff, this is not the spot for you. Citarella's is a no nonsense butcher that is a throwback to a bygone era. Deli sandwiches are really good, generous portions. Try the meatloaf (only available Thursday I believe) or the roast beef sandwich.
We moved to Red Bank recently and found Citarella's. My wife has called it a dream come true. Aged meats, home made sauces, ready to cook fresh and frozen dinners, sandwiches, sausages, fresh breads, cheeses, and cannoli cookies! Fresh herbs from the planters outside in season. What a welcome friendly family owned business.